Best gas in Colorado: octane, TOP TIER brands and ethanol-free fuel
Octane in Colorado
Each line is tagged by how well we could source it. Unverified lines are shown so you know they are not confirmed.
- verifiedColorado consumers have a choice of three grades of gasoline with an anti-knock index of 85, 87 and 91. The Division of Oil and Public Safety governs gasoline specifications under ASTM D4814 and Colorado statutes.[1] State agency statement as republished by a petroleum marketers' association.
- reportedAAA is quoted saying states offer 85 octane because of altitude; a former BP technical adviser says 85 is mostly sold along the Front Range.[2]
- reportedThe same fuels expert says the 91 premium grade across much of the West traces to pipeline logistics and California's lead, not to altitude.[2] One expert's explanation in a news report, not an official finding.
- verifiedFederal rule: every retailer must post the octane rating on each face of each gasoline dispenser, so the number on the pump is the legal posted rating.[3]
Why the grades look this way
Colorado's regulator says many Rocky Mountain states (Colorado, New Mexico, Utah, Wyoming, Montana, Idaho) still market an 85 octane regular because altitude lowers an engine's anti-knock requirement, and that studies it cites found no significant fuel-economy or air-quality penalty from 85 versus 87 at elevation.[1]
The U.S. fuel-economy site takes a more cautious line: 85 was originally allowed at high elevation because most carbureted engines tolerated it, that is not true of modern engines, and you should use the manufacturer-recommended fuel even where 85 is sold.[4]
If your owner's manual says 'premium required', the top grade sold locally is the grade to buy. Whether 91 here performs like 93 at sea level depends on the engine; we do not make that claim.
TOP TIER licensed brands in Colorado
TOP TIER licenses brands. The brand names below appear on the program's official U.S. list, which we last read by hand on 2026-11-18.[5] Brand-level only. Whether a particular station sells TOP TIER gasoline must be checked with the official Station Finder. Check any station with the official Station Finder; see our TOP TIER guide.
What OpenStreetMap shows for Colorado (an outline, not a station list)
Of 1,986 fuel map features in Colorado (2026-11-18 extract), 522 have no brand tag. Counts are map features, not stations (a station can be mapped twice), and volunteers tag some places and not others. Octane tags present: 100: 6, 85: 131, 86: 3, 87: 147, 88: 2, 89: 17, 91: 149, 92: 4, 93: 9, 95: 17, 98: 15. Features tagged ethanol-free: 2. That sparse coverage is why we do not list stations from this data. Contains information from OpenStreetMap, © OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL).[6]
| Brand on the official list | Mapped features |
|---|---|
| Conoco | 275 |
| Shell | 156 |
| Sinclair | 117 |
| Phillips 66 | 97 |
| Valero | 44 |
| Exxon | 38 |
| Diamond Shamrock | 29 |
| Costco / Kirkland Signature | 16 |
| Cenex | 14 |
| QuikTrip | 13 |
| Mobil | 9 |
| Marathon | 3 |
| 76 | 2 |
| Sunoco | 2 |
| CITGO | 1 |
| Brand tag | Mapped features | List status |
|---|---|---|
| Circle K | 103 | Not found on the official U.S. list when we checked |
| 7-Eleven | 101 | Not found on the official U.S. list when we checked |
| Maverik | 84 | Not found on the official U.S. list when we checked |
| King Soopers | 75 | Not checked by us |
| Loaf 'N Jug | 73 | Not found on the official U.S. list when we checked |
| Safeway | 40 | Not found on the official U.S. list when we checked |
| Kum & Go | 27 | Not found on the official U.S. list when we checked |
| Love's | 27 | Not found on the official U.S. list when we checked |
Ethanol-free gas in Colorado
- unverifiedWe have not yet found a Colorado-specific official source on how many stations sell ethanol-free gasoline. Nothing here claims availability at any station.
Colorado-specific ethanol-free coverage on this site is a work in progress. If you know a station that sells it, submit it below with the date you saw it. For a community-maintained lead, see pure-gas.org (linked, not copied) and our ethanol-free guide. Call the station before driving out of your way.
What people say
Opinions from public threads, quoted briefly. They are not facts, and we do not republish station recommendations from them.
“91 is effectively 93 at altitude. You're not really gonna find straight up 93 out here.”
r/grandjunction: '93 octane?' (May 2026). A commenter's view. We list it as what locals say, not as fact.
“I live in western Colorado, elevation 4500 feet. I cannot find 93 octane here for my new ZL1 Camaro.”
BobIsTheOilGuy forum: '93 octane not available. HELP'. Shows why a plain answer on the top grade is useful.
Submit a station in Colorado
Confirmed a station with the grade or ethanol-free fuel you were looking for? Email your submission
Placeholder form: this opens your email app. Send only what you saw yourself, with the date. Do not copy from other sites. We review before publishing and may ask for a photo of the pump label.
Nearby: Utah · Montana · Idaho
Page updated 2026-11-18. Spot a mistake? Send a correction with a source.
Sources
- Colorado Division of Oil and Public Safety response on 85 octane (republished by the Colorado Wyoming Petroleum Marketers Association) (state agency statement, republished by a trade association; accessed 2026-11-18)
- Colorado one of the few Western states that offer 91-octane gas (FOX31 Denver, Jun 4 2024) (news report (quotes AAA and a former BP fuels adviser); accessed 2026-11-18)
- 16 CFR 306.10 Automotive fuel rating posting (FTC rule, via Cornell LII) (federal; accessed 2026-11-18)
- Selecting the Right Octane Fuel (FuelEconomy.gov, U.S. DOE/EPA) (federal; accessed 2026-11-18)
- TOP TIER Approved Gasoline Brands (official list) (program owner; accessed 2026-11-18)
- OpenStreetMap (ODbL 1.0), state extracts from Geofabrik (open data; accessed 2026-11-18)